top of page

What Happens If You Over Contribute to Your 401(k) or IRA? A Physician's Tax Planning Guide to Fixing It

Nov 2
9 min read

Updated: Nov 9

You switched hospitals in July. Both payroll departments did exactly what you asked and took the same percentage from every paycheck. Neither one knew the other existed.

That's a classic way to end up with an excess 401(k) contribution, and nobody flags it at the time. You find out in March when your tax team adds up two W-2s, or a year later when the double tax has already locked in.

So what happens if you over contribute to your 401(k)? If you catch it early, you pay roughly the tax you'd have owed anyway. If you don't, you pay tax on the same money twice.

In this blog

What counts as an over contribution?

There isn't one retirement limit. The employee deferral limit, the overall cap per employer, and the IRA limit each work differently.

For the 2026 tax year (IRS Notice 2025-67):

  • Employee deferral limit (401(k) and 403(b) combined): $24,500

  • Catch up at age 50 or older: an extra $8,000

  • Catch up if you turn 60, 61, 62, or 63 in 2026: an extra $11,250 instead

  • Total annual additions to one employer's plans (your deferrals plus employer money, before catch up): $72,000

  • IRA limit across all traditional and Roth IRAs combined: $7,500, or $8,600 at 50 and older (IRS)

The deferral limit belongs to you, not your employer. The IRS says it plainly: it is "your individual limit each calendar year no matter how many plans you're in" (IRS). Two jobs do not mean two limits.

One exception helps a lot of academic physicians. A 457(b) plan has its own separate deferral limit that is not combined with your 403(b). Deferring the maximum to both in the same year is not an over contribution.

For the exact numbers and how the employer side is calculated, see our guide to solo 401(k) contribution limits for physicians.

What happens if you over contribute to your 401(k) or 403(b)?

It depends entirely on whether the excess comes out by April 15 of the following year.

If you fix it by April 15

The plan pays you back the excess plus whatever it earned. Then:

  • The excess itself is taxable for the year you deferred it, if it was a pretax deferral (2026 Form 1099-R instructions).

  • The earnings are taxable in the year they're paid out.

  • There is no 10% early withdrawal tax on a timely corrective distribution (26 U.S.C. 402(g)(2)(C)).

You owe tax on the excess once, the same as if you had never deferred it.

Designated Roth 401(k) deferrals are treated differently from pretax deferrals here. If the excess was Roth money, have your tax team walk through the correction with you rather than applying the rules above.

If you miss April 15

This is the expensive version. The IRS says uncorrected excess deferrals are "included in a participant's taxable income for the year contributed." Then they are "taxed a second time when the deferrals are ultimately distributed from the plan" (IRS).

You also get no credit for the first round of tax. Treasury regulations say an excess that isn't distributed by April 15 "is not treated as an investment in the contract" (Treas. Reg. 1.402(g)-1). Same dollars, taxed twice.

Wait, isn't there a 6% penalty?

Not for a 401(k). It's one of the most common mix ups online.

The 6% excise tax in IRC section 4973 applies to excess contributions in IRAs, HSAs, 403(b)(7) custodial accounts, Coverdell education accounts, Archer MSAs, and ABLE accounts. A 401(k) isn't on that list. Its penalty is the double tax described above.

How do you fix an excess 401(k) deferral?

Move fast, because the April 15 deadline doesn't move. Filing an extension on your return does not extend it.

  1. Add up every deferral you made during the calendar year, across every employer. Pull the year end pay stub from each one.

  2. Subtract your limit. For 2026 that is $24,500, plus any catch up you're eligible for.

  3. Decide which plan you'll ask to return the excess, and confirm that plan allows corrective distributions. With two employers involved, your tax team can help you pick.

  4. Contact that plan's administrator in writing and request a corrective distribution of the excess plus earnings. Ask early, because your plan may set a request date earlier than April 15.

  5. Confirm the money is out by April 15 of the following year (IRS).

  6. Report it on the right return. The pretax excess is income for the year you deferred it, even though the check arrives the next year.

When the plan issues your Form 1099-R, look at box 7. Code P means the amount is taxable in the prior year, and code 8 means it is taxable in the year you received it (IRS). The excess and its earnings often land on different returns.

Dr. Alvarez: the midyear job change

Dr. Alvarez is a 42 year old hospitalist who changed hospitals in July 2026.

  • Hospital A 401(k), January through June: $15,000

  • Hospital B 403(b), July through December: $12,000

  • Total deferrals for 2026: $27,000

  • 2026 limit (no catch up at 42): $24,500

  • Excess: $2,500

If she fixes it by April 15, 2027:

  • Hospital B returns $2,500 plus earnings.

  • The $2,500 is taxed once, on her 2026 return.

  • The earnings are taxed on her 2027 return.

  • No 10% additional tax.

If she misses April 15, 2027:

  • The $2,500 is still taxed on her 2026 return.

  • It stays in the plan with no tax basis.

  • It's taxed again when she withdraws it in retirement.

At a hypothetical 35% marginal rate in both years, that's about $875 of tax in 2026 and about $875 more at withdrawal. This example is for illustration. Your rates and results will differ.

What happens if you over contribute to a Roth or traditional IRA?

IRAs work on a different system, and they give you more time.

An excess IRA contribution is "taxed at 6% per year for each year the excess amounts remain in the IRA" (IRS). That 6% repeats every year until you fix it.

You can avoid it by taking out the excess, plus any earnings on it, by the due date of your tax return including extensions. That is a much longer window than the 401(k) April 15 deadline.

The physician version: a Roth contribution your income didn't allow

Plenty of attending physicians earn too much to contribute directly to a Roth IRA. For 2026, the ability to contribute phases out between $242,000 and $252,000 of modified AGI for joint filers, and between $153,000 and $168,000 for single filers (IRS Notice 2025-67).

Above those ranges, your Roth limit is zero. Anything you put in counts as an excess contribution.

You have two clean ways out:

  • Withdraw it. Take out the excess plus earnings by your extended filing deadline.

  • Recharacterize it. Have the contribution, plus its earnings, moved to a traditional IRA by the same deadline. The IRS treats it "as having been made to the other type of IRA" (IRS).

Recharacterizing is often the first step of a backdoor Roth: once the money is in a traditional IRA, you can convert it to a Roth. The IRS treats traditional to Roth conversions as a type of rollover. Ask your tax team whether the traditional contribution is deductible for you and how much of the conversion will be taxable.

Recharacterization only works on regular contributions. A conversion can't be recharacterized, and neither can a rollover from a 401(k) or 403(b) to a Roth IRA.

If you also hold pretax money in a SEP-IRA or traditional IRA, part of that conversion may be taxable. We explain why in the SEP-IRA trap and the backdoor Roth pro rata rule.

Dr. Chen: the accidental direct Roth

Dr. Chen is an anesthesiologist. She and her spouse file jointly with 2026 modified AGI of $310,000. In February 2026 she contributed $7,500 directly to her Roth IRA.

  • 2026 joint Roth phaseout ends at: $252,000

  • Her allowed Roth contribution: $0

  • Excess contribution: $7,500

  • 6% excise if left in: $450 for 2026, and another 6% for every later year it stays

The fix: before her extended 2026 filing deadline, she recharacterizes the $7,500 plus its earnings as a traditional IRA contribution. Then she can convert to Roth. The $450 never happens.

Where it shows up on your return

An uncorrected IRA or HSA excess is reported on IRS Form 5329. Part III covers traditional IRAs, Part IV covers Roth IRAs, and Part VII covers HSAs (Form 5329 instructions). The 6% itself is calculated on that form.

Where do over contributions come from?

Generic articles assume one job and one plan. Physicians rarely have that. These are the situations we see most.

Two W-2 employers in one year

A job change, a second hospital, or a July start as a new attending all create the Dr. Alvarez problem. Each payroll system resets your deferrals to zero. Your limit doesn't.

A W-2 job plus a 1099 solo 401(k)

If you're employed and also do locums or consulting on a 1099, your employee deferrals in the hospital plan and your solo 401(k) share one limit. Max out at the hospital and you have no employee deferral room left in the solo plan.

The employer side of the solo 401(k) is a separate question. Read our guide on how to set up a solo 401(k) as a 1099 physician before you fund it.

Overfunding the employer side of your own plan

In a solo 401(k), the employer contribution can be up to "25% of compensation as defined by the plan" (IRS). If you run an S-corp, compensation means your W-2 pay.

If you're a sole proprietor, compensation is your net self-employment earnings after subtracting half of your self-employment tax and the contribution itself. That makes the real number lower than 25% of your profit, and it is easy to overshoot.

Overshooting has its own cost. Contributions your practice can't deduct can face a 10% excise tax under IRC section 4972.

A 403(b) at the hospital plus your own practice

The $72,000 total cap applies across all plans of the same employer. Under Treasury regulations, all of an employer's defined contribution plans "are treated as one defined contribution plan" for this limit (Treas. Reg. 1.415(f)-1).

There's a twist for physicians. If you have a 403(b) and also control your own practice, the 403(b) can be treated as maintained by your practice too.

The two plans may then share one $72,000 cap. Whether that applies depends on ownership, so have your tax team check before funding both.

A refund check from your group's 401(k)

Traditional 401(k) plans must be tested each year to compare what highly compensated employees defer with what everyone else defers. For 2026, the pay threshold used to identify highly compensated employees is $160,000 (IRS Notice 2025-67), so many physicians are in that group.

When the plan fails, it refunds some of the highly compensated employees' deferrals, generally within 2 1/2 months after the plan year ends. "The refunded excess contribution is taxable to the HCE in the year of distribution" (IRS). Plan for that income on the return for the year the check arrives, not the year you deferred.

The Roth catch up rule for higher earners

Did your 2025 wages from the employer sponsoring your plan top $150,000? Then your 2026 catch up contributions generally have to go in as Roth (IRS Notice 2025-67). Final regulations formally apply from 2027, with a good faith standard for 2026 (Treas. Reg. 1.414(v)-2).

That means it can't go in pretax, so check how your plan is handling it.

Did you also over contribute to your HSA?

HSAs follow the IRA style rules. For 2026, the limit is $4,400 with self only high deductible coverage or $8,750 with family coverage (Rev. Proc. 2025-19), plus $1,000 if you're 55 or older (IRS Pub. 969).

Go over, and "you must pay a 6% excise tax on excess contributions" for each year the excess remains (IRS Pub. 969). To avoid it, withdraw the excess and its earnings by your return due date including extensions. The earnings are reported as income for the year you withdraw them.

Still deciding between an HSA and an FSA? See HSA vs. FSA for high income physicians.

Quick reference: which fix, which deadline?

Account

What went wrong

Deadline to fix

If you miss it

401(k) or 403(b) deferrals

Over the per person deferral limit

April 15 of the next year

Taxed twice

Traditional or Roth IRA

Over the limit, or Roth with income too high

Return due date, including extensions

6% excise every year

HSA

Over the 2026 HSA limit

Return due date, including extensions

6% excise every year

Solo 401(k) employer side

More than the practice can deduct

Before funding

Possible 10% excise on the nondeductible amount

Group 401(k) refund

Plan failed testing

Plan's job, not yours

Refund is taxable in the year received

Rules vary by state, and this guide covers federal tax only.

How can your tax team prevent an over contribution?

The over contributions we see usually start the same way: more than one payroll system, and nobody watching the total.

Tell us about a job change and we add up your deferrals before the new payroll starts. Planning a solo 401(k) contribution? We size the employer side against what the practice can deduct.

If your income rules out a direct Roth contribution, we flag it while there's still time to recharacterize. With 1099 income on top of a W-2 job, any correction gets built into your quarterly estimated taxes for 1099 physicians. That makes an April surprise far less likely.

Planning beyond the 401(k)? Start with cash balance plan contribution limits by age. Our physician retirement account tax planning guide shows how every account fits together.

Changing jobs or adding 1099 income this year? Contact your tax team today. Prompt, dependable communication, year round.



Doc Wealth logo with stethoscope icon

Contact Doc Wealth Today


Trusted by thousands of physicians nationwide for year-round tax planning, entity optimization, and strategies that make sense.


Disclaimer: This material is intended for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, accounting, or financial advice. The content is general in nature and may not apply to your specific circumstances. Tax laws and financial regulations are subject to change and interpretation, and the application of these laws can vary based on individual situations. Before making any decisions, you should consult with a qualified tax advisor, legal counsel, or financial professional.

Want To Receive Updates When Blogs Are Posted?

Enter your information below to be notified whenever a new blog is posted on the site.

bottom of page