Skip to main content

RAP or Old IBR: How to Think About the Choice

  • If your income is modest relative to debt (for example $90 000 AGI on $250 000 of loans):
    RAP’s early payment bands can cut your bill nearly in half compared with the 15 percent IBR rate, and the interest waiver prevents balance creep.
  • If you expect high earnings (surgeons, specialists, practice Owners):
    Old IBR keeps you capped at the Standard ten-year amount, while RAP rises with no ceiling. IBR often costs less once income soars.
  • If you work toward PSLF:
    Either plan qualifies, but lower RAP payments may leave more to forgive after your 120th payment—good if you stay in public service, risky if you leave.
  • If you aim to pay the debt off early:
    IBR’s 25-year horizon plus the cap generally burns through the balance sooner and with less total interest than RAP’s 30-year track.

Switching Has Consequences

Moving from IBR to RAP will capitalize any unpaid interest one time on the day you switch. After that, RAP’s monthly interest wipe keeps new charges from piling up, but the capitalized amount becomes part of your principal. You can switch plans once per year, so run the numbers before you jump. The newer post-2014 IBR, PAYE, or SAVE, have different capitalization caps and rules.

Also, your payment could go up because it’s likely been a while since you have recertified your income. If that’s the case and you want to switch, just wait until you’re forced to certify on IBR.

Q & A for 08-2014 Borrowers

  • Will I be moved automatically?
    No. You stay in IBR unless you file to change plans.
  • I’m in an Income Driven Repayment plan and haven’t recertified my income in years. When will I have to do it again?
    If you’re enrolled in an income driven repayment plan and haven’t recertified your income recently—likely due to pandemic-related pauses or extended administrative forbearance—you’re not alone. Millions of borrowers have seen their recertification dates re...
  • Should I Just Pay My Debt Off?
    If you borrowed a large amount for graduate school and you're already deep into an income-driven plan like IBR—or soon considering RAP—it’s worth running the numbers before rushing to pay everything off.Here’s what to consider:If forgiveness is on th...
  • When does interest capitalize on the old IBR plan?
    If you are determined to no longer have a ‘partial financial hardship’, fail to recertify your income by the deadline, or leave the IBR plan, interest is capitalized.
  • Will My Current Credit Toward Forgiveness Still Count?
    Yes, your existing qualifying payment count will carry over when you switch from PAYE to IBR or RAP—as long as you stay in an income-driven repayment (IDR) plan continuously.Here’s how it works:If you’ve made 120 qualifying payments under PAYE, and yo...